Sell cards in New York

42 more shops that buy cards in New York

Sorted by city. The proof that each one buys is next to its name.

• Fan Zone Albany · 3.7★ (50) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Sports Zone Albany · 4.3★ (149) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• SMR Collectibles | We Buy Sports Cards | We Buy Sports Memorabilia | We Sell Sports Cards Amityville · 4.2★ (77) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Double J’s Collectibles Amsterdam · 4.9★ (34) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Super Sport Cards Center Moriches · 4.6★ (82) Joe gave me such a great deal for my cards and I’ll definitely be back very soon.
• TCG DEPOT East Islip · 4.9★ (72) Aaron was very knowledgeable of market prices & I was able to trade in my cards for some products to rip.
• WNY Gaming and Escape Rooms Hamburg · 4.8★ (177) 1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.
• Cantrip Cards & Games Ithaca · 4.7★ (94) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Fat Cat Comics Johnson City · 4.7★ (187) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Fair Trade Games Kenmore · 4.6★ (43) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Pocket Lintz Games Lakewood · 5★ (14) I decided to head up and see what they had and trade in some cards!
• Bailey's Comics Lindenhurst · 4.8★ (133) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Three Ws TCG & More Lockport · 4.8★ (35) 1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.
• Solacido Cards and Collectibles Long Island City · 4.2★ (49) 1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.
• Card Shack Lynbrook · 4.6★ (162) Thank you Chris for giving me such a fair deal on my cards, and to the rest of the Card Shack crew!
• Prime 151 Collectibles Massapequa · 5★ (32) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• AAN Collect New Hartford · 4.8★ (122) We buy a lot of things from them as well as selling to them too.
• LIFE OF A SPORTS CARD LLC New Hartford · 5★ (11) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Ravenswood Comics New Hartford · 4.6★ (131) The only place we buy comics from!
• October Country Comics New Paltz · 4.6★ (118) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Alex's MVP Cards and Comics New York · 4.1★ (217) He bought my small collection for a favorable price.
• Niu Gaming By Niu Shop New York · 4.9★ (55) They offered me a great price for my cards—really appreciate it.
• Dame Games North Syracuse · 4.9★ (25) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Grand Slam Games & Comics Olean · 4★ (81) They buy cards too, usually at around 50-55% face value, which is fair compared to shops in Buffalo.
• Empyrean City Collectibles Oneida · 5★ (14) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• The Card Shop Plattsburgh · 4.8★ (167) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Chaos Goblin Games Poughkeepsie · 4.8★ (52) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Kirwan's Game Store Poughkeepsie · 4.1★ (204) 1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.
• Game On!! Rochester · 4.4★ (45) I just sold my collection to John.
• Leone’s Collectibles Rochester · 4.2★ (43) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Rochester CCG Rochester · 4.5★ (28) Got a good deal with my card
• TEK Game Studios Rochester · 5★ (8) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Standard Collectibles & Card Games Ronkonkoma · 4.9★ (45) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Grand Slam Collectibles Selden · 4.9★ (177) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Create-A-Card Inc Smithtown · 5★ (10) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Kyle's Comics Smithtown · 4.9★ (89) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• JC'S Cards and Collectibles Spencerport · 4.3★ (29) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• YouKnowItCards Staten Island · 4.7★ (115) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Professor Sam's Card Shop Tonawanda · 4.7★ (39) 1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.
• Mystify Games Waterloo · 3.8★ (33) They buy collections, they sell every active tcg, they pay more in cash and/or store credit than any other shop I've been to for your old rares, and collections.
• Legacy Games Webster · 4.9★ (188) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
• Gatsby's Game Cafe Westbury · 4.8★ (20) Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Where to sell cards in New York, by city

• New York 10 buyers
• Rochester 6 buyers
• Albany 3 buyers
• New Hartford 3 buyers
• Syracuse 3 buyers
• Poughkeepsie 2 buyers
• Smithtown 2 buyers
• Amityville 1 buyer
• Amsterdam 1 buyer
• Bellport 1 buyer
• Buffalo 1 buyer
• Center Moriches 1 buyer
• East Islip 1 buyer
• Elmont 1 buyer
• Glen Cove 1 buyer
• Hamburg 1 buyer
• Huntington 1 buyer
• Ithaca 1 buyer
• Johnson City 1 buyer
• Kenmore 1 buyer
• Lakewood 1 buyer
• Lindenhurst 1 buyer
• Lockport 1 buyer
• Long Island City 1 buyer
• Lynbrook 1 buyer
• Massapequa 1 buyer
• Mineola 1 buyer
• Nanuet 1 buyer
• New Paltz 1 buyer
• New Rochelle 1 buyer
• North Babylon 1 buyer
• North Syracuse 1 buyer
• Olean 1 buyer
• Oneida 1 buyer
• Plattsburgh 1 buyer
• Ronkonkoma 1 buyer
• Selden 1 buyer
• Spencerport 1 buyer
• Staten Island 1 buyer
• Tonawanda 1 buyer
• Waterloo 1 buyer
• Webster 1 buyer
• West Seneca 1 buyer
• Westbury 1 buyer

Before you go

1. Sort first. Separate your best cards from bulk and look up recent sold prices for the valuable ones.
2. Ask for cash and credit offers. Shops usually pay a share of market value in cash and more in store credit.
3. Call ahead. Ask if they are buying your game right now and when the buyer is in.
4. Get two offers. With 66 buyers in New York, you can compare before you sell.

More tips on the sell your cards page.