Home › Sell your cards › New York › Smithtown

Sell cards in Smithtown

2 card shops in Smithtown, New York buy cards, out of 3 listed in the city. Each one is here because its customers' reviews or its own website say it buys. Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews.

Kyle's Comics

4.9★

1029 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY

Buys collections Pokémon
4.9Rating
89Reviews
1Games
Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Create-A-Card Inc

5★

155 E Main St #270, Smithtown, NY

Buys collections
5Rating
10Reviews
—Games
Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Getting a fair offer in Smithtown

  1. Know what you have. Sort by game and set, and look up recent sold prices for your best cards. A shop prices an unsorted box with caution.
  2. Get offers from more than one shop. Kyle's Comics and Create-A-Card Inc may want different cards, so the same stack can get different offers.
  3. Ask for the store-credit price too. Shops usually pay more in credit than in cash. Take it if you would spend it there anyway.
  4. Call before a big trip. Ask whether they are buying your game right now, when the buyer is in, and whether to bring a photo ID.

All card shops in Smithtown, NY → · Sell cards elsewhere in New York →