Home › New York › Buffalo › Heart Of The Game

Heart Of The Game in Buffalo, NY

4.4 ★★★★☆ 594 Google reviews

Buys collections Yu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The GatheringPokémon

Heart Of The Game sells trading cards at 85 S Rossler Ave, Buffalo, NY. It has a 4.4-star rating from 594 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon and Digimon.

Games carried

Each game is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • “I love that is one of few stores that still have Yu-Gi-Oh singles, and binders” (Google review)

    Mentioned 4 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • Magic: The Gathering

    More Magic shops →

    “This store literally has it all, I went in on one of their MtG nights and it was the most ridiculous amount of fun Ive had in quite sometime!” (Google review)

    Mentioned 3 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • “Wide selection of magic, pokemon and video games.” (Google review)

    Mentioned once in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • Listed on the shop's website

Sell your cards here?

Reviews of Heart Of The Game mention selling cards to the shop.

Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now and whether they pay cash or store credit.

Where to sell trading cards

What collectors say

  • Tournaments & events

    “From retro gaming, events to TCG, this place has it.” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

  • Big singles selection

    “I love that is one of few stores that still have Yu-Gi-Oh singles, and binders” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

From Google reviews

OMG! This store literally has it all, I went in on one of their MtG nights and it was the most ridiculous amount of fun Ive had in quite sometime! The staff are incredibly knowledgeable, very kind and fair when selling older cards or just in general, and they have just about any game you can think of!

★★★★★ Michael, Jan 2026

One of the best experiences at a game/card shop I’ve ever had. Every worker was kind and inviting, and they honored a deal we had discussed on the phone despite making additional sales of the same items throughout the day that technically would have lowered what they wanted to offer me.

★★★★★ Max, Jun 2026

Absolutely amazing place! On site console and card battles. The best trade in value for your old consoles, games and accessories alike! The customer service is beyond anything I’ve ever experienced. I walked in looking for a charger, and they didn’t have one in stock new so they gave me a used one for free.

★★★★★ Thomaslee, Jul 2023

Honest, hard working people. The store has that comforting atmosphere and the workers are just as great. Drew helped me with my issue with a preorder and quickly resolved my issue. I was grateful for his honestly and help. I can’t stress how great this place is and how much they respect their consumers.

★★★★★ Ronald, Sep 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 594 on Google →

Where to find Heart Of The Game

More card shops nearby

2070 Clinton St, Cheektowaga, NY

Magic: The GatheringSports cards
4.9Rating
139Reviews
2Games

Under a mile away

Top Cut Cards

4.7★

43 Kelly Dr, Cheektowaga, NY

PokémonYu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The Gathering
4.7Rating
74Reviews
5Games

2.9 miles away

1026 Union Rd, West Seneca, NY

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering
4.5Rating
237Reviews
3Games

3.8 miles away

1052 Union Rd, West Seneca, NY

PokémonSports cards
4.4Rating
20Reviews
2Games

3.8 miles away

A Cardstore

4.2★

4018 Union Rd, Buffalo, NY

PokémonDigimonYu-Gi-Oh!
4.2Rating
436Reviews
4Games

3.9 miles away

2120 George Urban Blvd, Depew, NY

PokémonOne PieceMagic: The Gathering
4.7Rating
64Reviews
3Games

4.4 miles away

All card shops in Buffalo, NY →

Card shops in nearby cities

All card shops in New York →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.