Home › New York › Westbury › Gatsby's Game Cafe

Gatsby's Game Cafe in Westbury, NY

4.8 ★★★★★ 20 Google reviews

Buys collections New shop Magic: The GatheringLorcana

Gatsby's Game Cafe sells trading cards at 1500 Old Country Rd Second Floor, Unit 243, Westbury, NY. It has a 4.8-star rating from 20 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Magic: The Gathering and Lorcana.

Games carried

Each game is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • Magic: The Gathering

    More Magic shops →

    “Hope to see everyone at FNM, future pre-releases, and commander Thursdays!” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • Mentioned 2 times in reviews

Sell your cards here?

Gatsby's Game Cafe buys cards, per the shop's website.

Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now and whether they pay cash or store credit.

Where to sell trading cards

What collectors say

  • Tournaments & events

    “Two of us attended their Blood on the Clocktower event for the first time, and we left wondering why we hadn't discovered it sooner.” (Google review)

    Mentioned 4 times in reviews

From Google reviews

Fantastic game spot! My husband and I stumbled across this shop yesterday and we had such a great experience! While the shop hasn’t had the grand opening yet, we were fortunate to experience the “soft opening” along with a couple other groups that walked in. The staff were knowledgeable, incredibly kind, and welcoming!

★★★★★ Christina, Feb 2026

Stumbled upon this board game cafe the other day while wandering the mall - and oh, my goodness, I cannot wait to return! It’s a beautiful, well-spaced board game cafe filled with so many games I’ve never seen that I’d love to play (only costs adults $15 for 3hrs of play, which is a great day), as well as other things…

★★★★★ Evelyn, Feb 2026

Loved it a lot! Went there today, played Biome and Boop!. Affordable prices, and a crazy high selection, will definetly be back a bunch of times. The games we tried were super fun and not too hard to get into. The selection of dice they offer are very high quality as well. Food and chai latte was okay.

★★★★★ Tiny, Mar 2026

What an amazing first experience at Gatsby's Game Cafe! Two of us attended their Blood on the Clocktower event for the first time, and we left wondering why we hadn't discovered it sooner.

★★★★★ Mark, Jun 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 20 on Google →

Where to find Gatsby's Game Cafe

More card shops nearby

1500 Old Country Rd 2nd Floor, Westbury, NY

Pokémon
4.9Rating
158Reviews
1Games

Under a mile away

455 Maple Ave, Westbury, NY

Pokémon
5Rating
395Reviews
1Games

Under a mile away

A & S Sports

4.5★

825 Carman Ave, Westbury, NY

Sports cardsPokémon
4.5Rating
362Reviews
2Games

2.2 miles away

Card smart

4.5★

1941 Front St, East Meadow, NY

4.5Rating
15Reviews
—Games

2.2 miles away

22 Mitchell Ct, Hempstead, NY

—Rating
—Reviews
—Games

2.3 miles away

466 Jericho Tpke, Mineola, NY

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémonOne Piece
5Rating
222Reviews
3Games

3.1 miles away

All card shops in Westbury, NY →

Card shops in nearby cities

All card shops in New York →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.