Home › New York › Waterloo › Mystify Games
Mystify Games in Waterloo, NY
Mystify Games sells trading cards at 655 NY-318 #47, Waterloo, NY. It has a 3.8-star rating from 33 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece and Lorcana.
Games carried
-
Pokémon
More Pokémon shops →“Very helpful when I was asking questions about going through some old Pokemon card binders we came across.” (Google review)
Mentioned 7 times in reviews
-
Magic: The Gathering
More Magic shops →“If you are looking for MTG, Yugioh, or Universes they are a great local shop looking to grow their community.” (Google review)
Mentioned 6 times in reviews
-
Yu-Gi-Oh!
More Yu-Gi-Oh! shops →Same review as Magic: The Gathering, above.
Mentioned 2 times in reviews
-
One Piece
More One Piece shops →Mentioned 2 times in reviews
-
Lorcana
More Lorcana shops →“Whether it be DnD, Pokémon, lorcana, yugioh, or mtg they can help.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
Sell your cards here?
“They buy collections, they sell every active tcg, they pay more in cash and/or store credit than any other shop I've been to for your old rares, and collections.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now and whether they pay cash or store credit.
What collectors say
-
Big singles selection
“Very friendly staff and a decent selection of Pokemon singles and affordable” (Google review)
Mentioned 5 times in reviews
-
Play space
“Lots of tables and space for gaming.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
-
Sealed product
Mentioned 4 times in reviews
From Google reviews
Honestly this is one of nicest small shops around and the owners are amazing! I am hoping that the community will continue to grow. If you are looking for MTG, Yugioh, or Universes they are a great local shop looking to grow their community. Would highly recommend visiting!
I decided to stop in during my vacation to check their magic the gathering collection. While small, they had a good collection of cards to go through, and they were very nice and personable. Definitely recommend!
A nice selection of pokemon and magic cards! The owner was very nice and pleasant to talk to! I bought my five year old and she enjoyed her time there as well.
I just want to brag for a minute about how awesome this store is. I have never been to it before the 7th of August and when I went in I wasn't expecting to buy anything from them. While I was walking around I found something for my cousin when I went to pay for it there was a little basket or bowl with stickers in it.
Where to find Mystify Games
More card shops nearby
Bear & Vine
4.7★
Cash 4 Games CNY
4.7★
Card shops in nearby cities
- Geneva2 card shops
- Seneca Falls1 card shop
- Phelps2 card shops
- Auburn3 card shops
- Canandaigua1 card shop
- Wolcott1 card shop
- Elbridge1 card shop
- Victor1 card shop