Home › Sell your cards › Indiana

Sell cards in Indiana

34 card shops in Indiana buy cards, out of 225 listed in the state. We list a shop as a buyer only when its customers' reviews or its own website say it buys. The proof is under each shop. Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews.

Mega Replay Fort Wayne

4.3★

5511 Coldwater Rd, Fort Wayne, IN

Buys collections PokémonYu-Gi-Oh!

4.3Rating

2,161Reviews

2Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

The Hobby Den

5★

5432 E Indiana St, Evansville, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cards

5Rating

921Reviews

2Games

He gave me a great price and also arranged for the extras of my husband’s collection to be donated. From a customer review.

The Book Broker

4.3★

2717 Covert Ave, Evansville, IN

Buys collections Magic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!Sports cards

4.3Rating

705Reviews

4Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Crown Point Toys and Collectibles

4.6★

1189 E Summit St, Crown Point, IN

Buys collections

4.6Rating

426Reviews

—Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Indy Card Exchange

4.7★

7035 E 96th St Ste p, Indianapolis, IN

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémon

4.7Rating

394Reviews

2Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Game Time

4.2★

8244 Center Run Dr, Indianapolis, IN

Buys collections PokémonMagic: The Gathering

4.2Rating

399Reviews

2Games

1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.

Baseball Card Exchange

4.1★

709b US-41, Schererville, IN

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémonMagic: The Gathering

4.1Rating

296Reviews

3Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

DZ Gaming

4.6★

124 W Monroe St, Decatur, IN

Buys collections Magic: The Gathering

4.6Rating

223Reviews

1Games

1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.

Sport Spot Inc

4.6★

1015 E Coliseum Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cards

4.6Rating

210Reviews

2Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

KeyCards LLC

4.9★

409 Spring St, Jeffersonville, IN

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!

4.9Rating

185Reviews

3Games

They also buy cards at a good price 80% for unopened and 70% for single cards at market price on TCG Player. From a customer review.

The Gaming Outpost

4.8★

192 W Joliet St A, Crown Point, IN

Buys collections PokémonDigimon

4.8Rating

170Reviews

2Games

1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.

Collectors Emporium

4.7★

17681 Cumberland Rd, Noblesville, IN

Buys collections PokémonOne Piece

4.7Rating

173Reviews

2Games

My son wanted to trade in some Pokemon cards for store credit after a friend recommended this place. From a customer review.

K & L Cards

4.2★

3100 Meridian Parke Dr Ste Z, Greenwood, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

4.2Rating

174Reviews

3Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING

4.7★

900 Tutor Ln #104, Evansville, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

4.7Rating

146Reviews

3Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Paradigm Games

4.7★

2479 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN

Buys collections PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece

4.7Rating

139Reviews

3Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

The Sports Card Shop

4.6★

118 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémon

4.6Rating

138Reviews

2Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Infinite TCG

3.8★

1509 Goshen Ave, Fort Wayne, IN

Buys collections PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

3.8Rating

145Reviews

6Games

Good price for bulk cards. I refreshed my collection of Magic cards here. From a customer review.

Fan Cave

4.4★

4805 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

4.4Rating

125Reviews

3Games

First time I came and sold my baseball collection. From a customer review.

Crafty Coins

4.4★

2126 Inwood Dr, Fort Wayne, IN

Buys collections PokémonOne PieceLorcana

4.4Rating

118Reviews

3Games

1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.

D20 Dungeon

5★

2501 Wheeling Ave, Muncie, IN

Buys collections Magic: The GatheringPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!

5Rating

94Reviews

5Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Nicodemus Cards & Gaming

4.5★

151 S High St, Warsaw, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

4.5Rating

99Reviews

6Games

I brought my son in to trade in some Pokémon cards and had a great experience. From a customer review.

Card Guys Sports & TCG

4.8★

413 Main St, Jasper, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

4.8Rating

74Reviews

5Games

I recently sold my collection of high-end cards, and the entire experience was outstanding. From a customer review.

Mascot Sports Cards & Collectibles

4.8★

705 Main St, Tell City, IN

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

4.8Rating

73Reviews

5Games

Sold my collection today very nice and it is a fun environment. From a customer review.

Michiana Sports Cards

4.6★

12980 Adams Rd, Granger, IN

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémonMagic: The Gathering

4.6Rating

73Reviews

3Games

Buys cards, per the shop's website.

10 more shops that buy cards in Indiana

Sorted by city. The proof that each one buys is next to its name.

All American Sports Cards Clarksville · 2.4★ (84) 1 customer review mentions selling or trading in cards here.
Hood’s Hobby House Columbus · 3.3★ (9) Plenty of things to choose from no matter what kind of card collector you are and they also buy cards.
The Trainer Pack Granger · 5★ (59) He gave me a great offer on my collection and reignited my passion for card collecting :) Thank you so much for everything
Nani Entertainment LLC Indianapolis · 5★ (15) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
Abrams Cards and Collectibles Knox · 4.7★ (13) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
Cards & JEM'S La Porte · 4.2★ (5) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
Card Stocks Lawrenceburg · 4.5★ (16) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
NWI Cards Merrillville · 4.6★ (54) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
Indiana Sportscard Guys Milford · 4.8★ (65) Buys cards, per the shop's website.
Uptown Comics, Cards, & Collectibles by Normal Block Entertainment Valparaiso · 4.5★ (17) Glad they gave me a fair offer for my bulk cards came out on a solid discount on the ETB box I got, great guys, I appreciate the deal!

Where to sell cards in Indiana, by city

Indianapolis 5 buyers
Fort Wayne 4 buyers
Evansville 3 buyers
Crown Point 2 buyers
Granger 2 buyers
Valparaiso 2 buyers
Clarksville 1 buyer
Columbus 1 buyer
Decatur 1 buyer
Greenwood 1 buyer
Jasper 1 buyer
Jeffersonville 1 buyer
Knox 1 buyer
La Porte 1 buyer
Lawrenceburg 1 buyer
Merrillville 1 buyer
Milford 1 buyer
Muncie 1 buyer
Noblesville 1 buyer
Schererville 1 buyer
Tell City 1 buyer
Warsaw 1 buyer

Before you go

Sort first. Separate your best cards from bulk and look up recent sold prices for the valuable ones.
Ask for cash and credit offers. Shops usually pay a share of market value in cash and more in store credit.
Call ahead. Ask if they are buying your game right now and when the buyer is in.
Get two offers. With 34 buyers in Indiana, you can compare before you sell.

More tips on the sell your cards page.

All card shops in Indiana → · Other states →