Home › Indiana › Warsaw › Nicodemus Cards & Gaming

Nicodemus Cards & Gaming in Warsaw, IN

4.5 ★★★★★ 99 Google reviews

Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering

Nicodemus Cards & Gaming sells trading cards at 151 S High St, Warsaw, IN. It has a 4.5-star rating from 99 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Pokémon, sports cards, Magic: The Gathering, Lorcana, Yu-Gi-Oh! and One Piece.

Games carried

Each game is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • “My 7 year old son has just recently started actually collecting Pokemon cards and he is obsessed with this place so much that he’s started acting like he owns his own Pokémon shop.” (Google review)

    Mentioned 8 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • “Also, they have sports cards, board games, Lorcana stuff, and lots more.” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • Magic: The Gathering

    More Magic shops →

    “MTG offering has expanded.” (Google review)

    Mentioned once in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • Same review as Sports cards, above.

    Mentioned once in reviews · Listed on the shop's website

  • Listed on the shop's website

  • “It's a cozy place with wall to wall goodies: pokemon, one piece, magic etc.” (Google review)

    Mentioned once in reviews

Sell your cards here?

“I brought my son in to trade in some Pokémon cards and had a great experience.” (Google review)

Mentioned once in reviews

Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now and whether they pay cash or store credit.

Where to sell trading cards

What collectors say

  • Tournaments & events

    “the events that are held, at least for Pokemon, are always ran pretty well, and there's a sizeable, friendly community here!” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

From Google reviews

Went in there last Sunday… they walked me thru as a new sports card investor as to what all of the different brands were and just helped me with an abundant of knowledge… they didn’t push me to buy anything I didn’t want.

★★★★★ Martin, Nov 2024

lovely place, friendly and helpful staff, have never had a bad experience myself here, items are priced fairly. makes my day every time i visit and not just because of the cards i pull (sometimes i’m not even making a purchase myself if i’m not in the money for it) small space but doesn’t make me feel claustrophobic…

★★★★★ F, Mar 2025

We just found out about Nicodemus about a month ago and we absolutely love it. The staff is so kind and friendly. My 7 year old son has just recently started actually collecting Pokemon cards and he is obsessed with this place so much that he’s started acting like he owns his own Pokémon shop.

★★★★★ Mikayla, Aug 2026

Always welcoming to all people. They are excited to share your passion for any game and help find something you're looking for or even something new! Best place to go for all my card collecting needs.

★★★★★ Nicholas, Apr 2025

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 99 on Google →

Where to find Nicodemus Cards & Gaming

More card shops nearby

406 W 4th St, Milford, IN

Buys collections Sports cards
4.8Rating
65Reviews
1Games

12.0 miles away

136 W Walker Way, Columbia City, IN

Pokémon
4.9Rating
179Reviews
1Games

19.6 miles away

218 N Main St, Goshen, IN

—Rating
—Reviews
—Games

24.3 miles away

320 N Chicago Ave Ste 8, Goshen, IN

PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece
4.9Rating
47Reviews
3Games

24.4 miles away

FYC Comics

4.9★

118 N Michigan St, Plymouth, IN

Pokémon
4.9Rating
51Reviews
1Games

24.7 miles away

Got Game

4.6★

118 W Laporte St, Plymouth, IN

Magic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!
4.6Rating
88Reviews
2Games

24.7 miles away

All card shops in Warsaw, IN →

Card shops in nearby cities

All card shops in Indiana →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.