Finger Lakes Sports Cards in Geneva, NY

Fingerlakes Sports Cards is inside Penny Lane, (with 2floors and a hundred ish other vendors, the rest of the non sports squad have other things to look at) main floor, center aisle second to last on your right& there’s a sign above for treasures upstairs- Steve’s thought of everything!

Finger Lakes Sport Cards is a true gem for collectors! Whether you're new to the hobby or a seasoned collector, this shop has something for everyone—sealed boxes, singles, graded cards, and plenty of knowledge to go around.

It's always a pleasure to work out a trade or purchase! Thanks so much for always working with me and hitting me up when you get in amazing vintage cards. I drive almost 2 hours to work out deals and it's always worth it!!

I love this place. I've bought many cards from there and it's always been a great experience. Thousands of cards to pick through, from vintage to modern. Owner is a pleasure to deal with and is more than willing to make fair deals. If you're into card collecting I would highly reccomend checking this place out!