Home › Best card shops › New Jersey
Best card shops in New Jersey
How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 222 of the 263 card shops we list in New Jersey qualify; these are the top 10.
-
#1 CARDS 2 GO
4.9★★★★★ 1,981 reviews
Buys collections PokémonYu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The GatheringOne Piece“I was here on May 22nd for the release of Chaos Rising and it was very fun. Awesome the fact that basically this event was for the collectors and not scalpers. The guy in front of the store was very p…”
-
#2 Monmouth Cards
4.8★★★★★ 1,453 reviews
Buys collections PokémonOne PieceSports cardsMagic: The Gathering“They resolve my problem quick, we communicated the right way and the product are top notch I recommend them if u want to start collecting this is the place”
-
#3 The Retro Game Cave
4.9★★★★★ 1,186 reviews
Pokémon“In all my times of dealing with shams and products that shouldn’t be advertised as like new/used condition whether it’s Gamestop or Mercari/ebay; this place has everything you could ask for.”
-
#4 CARDS 2 GO
5★★★★★ 1,124 reviews
Buys collections PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!One Piece“Every time I go in all the staff is so incredibly nice!! Spent 10 bucks on a pack of gempack vol. 2, Jun let me pick out a pack and I hit big!!! Huge thanks to the whole staff in there— esp Jun!!! 🌟�…”
-
#5 Sell Your Gadgets - Cash For Electronics
4.9★★★★★ 938 reviews
Buys collections Pokémon“Ahmed & Tom were very helpful from the time I called to the time I walked in. They went above and beyond to help me get a good price. I highly recommend them. Such sweet gentleman. Soo kind and patien…”
-
#6 Top Deck Games
4.6★★★★★ 876 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece“Top Deck was all I expected and more. The selection was expansive and impressive. The decorum was pleasing. The selection and knowledge of Staff was top notch. Sadly my wallet forced my restraint but…”
-
#7 True Believers Gaming & Collectibles
4.7★★★★★ 780 reviews
Pokémon“Bought a fat pikachu along with a few other beautiful cards with the help of David. David does a great job at assisting customers and deserves more reviews for how awesome he is. We need more German f…”
-
#8 Monmouth Cards
4.9★★★★★ 738 reviews
PokémonSports cardsMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!“I had a great experience at Monmouth Trading Cards Store. The customer service was outstanding—everyone was friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about the hobby. The staff took the time t…”
-
#9 Monmouth Cards
4.9★★★★★ 727 reviews
PokémonSports cardsMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!“Nick Scelfo was a great help. Very friendly guy, who had an answer for every question. Helped me find what I wanted, even gave me recommendations on where to eat after. When I tell you he knew every r…”
-
#10 Monmouth Cards
4.9★★★★★ 688 reviews
PokémonSports cardsMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!“Jake was great really helpful with my son on teaching what cards are the best to look for. This review would've been 10 stars but I happened to look up and see Joey wearing a Cowboys hat!!”
