Home › Sell your cards › Ohio › Columbus

Sell cards in Columbus

4 card shops in Columbus, Ohio buy cards, out of 16 listed in the city. Each one is here because its customers' reviews or its own website say it buys. Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews.

Midwest Cards

4.9★

401 N Front St #95, Columbus, OH

Buys collections Sports cardsPokémonMagic: The Gathering
4.9Rating
2,171Reviews
4Games
Buys cards, per the shop's website.

The Soldiery Games & Cards

4.4★

4256 N High St, Columbus, OH

Buys collections Magic: The GatheringPokémon
4.4Rating
711Reviews
2Games
We are pretty casual, kitchen table players, but that being said, we buy every set and keep up with everything. From a customer review.

The Warp Gate

4.4★

4499 Kenny Rd, Columbus, OH

Buys collections Magic: The GatheringPokémonDigimon
4.4Rating
403Reviews
7Games
Buys cards, per the shop's website.

Forever Games

4.7★

374 B Morrison Rd, Columbus, OH

Buys collections PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!
4.7Rating
223Reviews
3Games
Was able to purchase a 2DS XL (clamshell model) for a reasonable price which helped me kickstart my 3DS collection. From a customer review.

Getting a fair offer in Columbus

  1. Know what you have. Sort by game and set, and look up recent sold prices for your best cards. A shop prices an unsorted box with caution.
  2. Get offers from more than one shop. Midwest Cards and The Soldiery Games & Cards may want different cards, so the same stack can get different offers.
  3. Ask for the store-credit price too. Shops usually pay more in credit than in cash. Take it if you would spend it there anyway.
  4. Call before a big trip. Ask whether they are buying your game right now, when the buyer is in, and whether to bring a photo ID.

All card shops in Columbus, OH → · Sell cards elsewhere in Ohio →