Home › Florida › Orange Park › Secret Rare Gaming
Secret Rare Gaming in Orange Park, FL
Secret Rare Gaming sells trading cards at 1670 Wells Rd #104, Orange Park, FL. It has a 4.5-star rating from 46 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh! and One Piece.
Games carried
-
Pokémon
More Pokémon shops →“Decent selection of magic and pokemon and the cherry on top were the retro consoles and play tables!” (Google review)
Mentioned 3 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website
-
Magic: The Gathering
More Magic shops →“A great store with some cool singles and fun commander nights Trades are fair and the vibe is great” (Google review)
Mentioned 2 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website
-
Yu-Gi-Oh!
More Yu-Gi-Oh! shops →“Decent selection of MTG, Pokémon, and Yu-Gi-Oh for a newer shop.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
-
One Piece
More One Piece shops →“Newer shop so he didn't have what I was looking for yet (one piece stuff) said he was still working on his distributers, but he was very friendly and seemed to know his stuff.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
Sell your cards here?
Reviews of Secret Rare Gaming mention selling cards to the shop.
Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now and whether they pay cash or store credit.
What collectors say
-
Tournaments & events
“Their prices are fair and I love that they have a limit on sealed product to prevent scalping.” (Google review)
Mentioned 2 times in reviews
-
Big singles selection
“He was very friendly, the singles I purchased were competitively priced, and he offered my friend and I to come back and play him in a game of commander when we had time.” (Google review)
Mentioned 5 times in reviews
From Google reviews
The owner was there on Friday, 6/12/26. He was very friendly, the singles I purchased were competitively priced, and he offered my friend and I to come back and play him in a game of commander when we had time. The vibe of the store was pleasant!
Just moved to the area and randomly stopped in. Super friendly staff who was a great help to recommend local card shows and TCG events. Decent selection of MTG, Pokémon, and Yu-Gi-Oh for a newer shop. Added a few singles to my PC so it was an overall great experience.
I had a friend who loved nerd stuff especially at lunch he was a know it all and talked non stop that I couldn't even eat because then he will say that I wasn't listening and paying attention to him which bothered me 💀 he still sat next to me and talked un invited still even when I hid from him like 3-4th grade thank…
Great place to go if you want to add to your collection or just play a few games. I mainly go for Battletech but they do trading cards as well. The employees are great people who will join you in a game or two and also provide a lot of knowledge if you have any questions regarding their producsts or the rules for any…
Where to find Secret Rare Gaming
More card shops nearby
Erkz Card Bazaar
4.3★
Counterspell Games
4.7★
Vortex Cards & Games
4.6★
Card shops in nearby cities
- Jacksonville13 card shops
- Green Cove Springs1 card shop
- St Johns1 card shop
- Ponte Vedra Beach1 card shop
- Yulee1 card shop
- St. Augustine5 card shops
- Palatka1 card shop
- Fernandina Beach1 card shop