Home › Ohio › Eastlake › Over the Fence
Over the Fence in Eastlake, OH
Over the Fence sells trading cards at 35125 Vine St Unit 1, Eastlake, OH. It has a 4.2-star rating from 140 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries sports cards, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh!.
Games carried
-
Sports cards
More sports card shops →“The very first shop I visited was Over the Fence Sports Cards, and honestly, it reminded me exactly why I loved this hobby in the first place.” (Google review)
Mentioned 12 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website
-
Pokémon
More Pokémon shops →“Whether you’re into sports cards, Pokémon, or collectibles, this is definitely a spot worth checking out.” (Google review)
Mentioned 6 times in reviews
-
Yu-Gi-Oh!
More Yu-Gi-Oh! shops →“I bought a 15$ small booster box of "yugioh's" hidden arsenal chapter 1 and pulled BOTH chase cards in the same pack.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
What collectors say
-
Sealed product
“I bought a 15$ small booster box of "yugioh's" hidden arsenal chapter 1 and pulled BOTH chase cards in the same pack.” (Google review)
Mentioned 3 times in reviews
From Google reviews
I bought a 15$ small booster box of "yugioh's" hidden arsenal chapter 1 and pulled BOTH chase cards in the same pack. Worth 10x of what that box costs...I've never had better luck than a private card seller compared to retail like Target and Walmart. Well worth the journey. Will be back.
I just got back into the hobby in February 2026 after not collecting cards since I was a kid over 30 years ago. The very first shop I visited was Over the Fence Sports Cards, and honestly, it reminded me exactly why I loved this hobby in the first place. From the moment I walked in, I felt like a kid again.
Awesome shop with a great selection and fair prices. The staff was super friendly, knowledgeable, and took time to help me find exactly what I was looking for. had a really welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re into sports cards, Pokémon, or collectibles, this is definitely a spot worth checking out.
Came here for some cards, stayed a bit for Nolan! The card shop has a lot of variety for all card hobbyists and if you're a dog lover Nolan is the friendliest storefront employee ive ever met! I will keep coming back here, love the selection and the owner is friendly too
Where to find Over the Fence
More card shops nearby
Comic Heaven
4.6★
Vallar comics
4.9★
North Coast Games
4.8★
Shuffler's Den
4.7★
Card shops in nearby cities
- Willoughby3 card shops
- Wickliffe1 card shop
- Willoughby Hills2 card shops
- Mentor4 card shops
- Lyndhurst2 card shops
- Painesville2 card shops
- Cleveland Heights2 card shops
- Beachwood1 card shop