Home › Wisconsin › Milwaukee › Old Guard Games

Old Guard Games in Milwaukee, WI

4.9 ★★★★★ 133 Google reviews

Magic: The Gathering

Old Guard Games sells trading cards at 3132 N Downer Ave, Milwaukee, WI. It has a 4.9-star rating from 133 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Magic: The Gathering.

Games carried

Each game is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • Magic: The Gathering

    More Magic shops →

    “Every time I decide to go there for a MTG night.” (Google review)

    Mentioned once in reviews

What collectors say

  • Play space

    “Lots of tables for playing tabletop war games and a private room for role-playing.” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

From Google reviews

Came in yesterday after the Adepticon wargame convention. They have such a huge selection of historical miniatures, the largest volume AND variety I've seen in any physical store! And at pretty reasonable prices too.

★★★★★ James, Mar 2026

10/10 Me and my friend went there and drooled (not actually, that'd be gross) over the abundance of tables, dice, goblins, clone troopers and warhammer bits and bobs. Upon checkout (with two measly lime sodas, else we'd likely bankrupt ourselves if we allowed even one purchase of figurines and books.

★★★★★ Mod, Sep 2026

Godspeed to Old Guard Games on Downer. They have brought something truly unique and special to the SE WI gaming scene. Playing spaces, lighting, music (had Band of Brothers OST playing), bathrooms, decor and pricing are all done right. A true Midwest if not national gaming destination.

★★★★★ Tim, May 2024

The best game store I've ever been to. They have a whole basement with big tables and tons of different terrain to use. A great place to shop and play with a huge selection. The community the store has, along with the staff are very welcoming. 11/10 would recommend

★★★★★ Gerryck, Jun 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 133 on Google →

Where to find Old Guard Games

More card shops nearby

1920 E Capitol Dr, Shorewood, WI

Buys collections PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece
4.7Rating
134Reviews
4Games

1.0 miles away

The Slab

4.7★

4451 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI

4.7Rating
3Reviews
—Games

1.6 miles away

NexGen Cards

4.7★

1432 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI

PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!
4.7Rating
86Reviews
4Games

1.7 miles away

1220 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI

PokémonMagic: The GatheringFlesh and Blood
4.9Rating
36Reviews
4Games

1.8 miles away

5754 N Bayshore Dr, Glendale, WI

PokémonMagic: The GatheringLorcana
4.6Rating
257Reviews
4Games

3.7 miles away

6805 N Green Bay Ave, Glendale, WI

PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!
4.8Rating
106Reviews
5Games

5.4 miles away

All card shops in Milwaukee, WI →

Card shops in nearby cities

All card shops in Wisconsin →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.