Lost Trove Collectibles in New Berlin, WI

This place is a hidden gem! At first you kinda question whether or not you are in the right place because you enter from the back, but believe me, you are! The owner is an incredibly kind individual, super helpful, and extremely knowledgeable!

Great service and a very friendly owner made this shop a pleasure to visit. It’s the perfect spot for GI Joe, Transformers, Star Wars, Marvel/DC, Godzilla, and just about any other “nerdy” collectibles you can think of. Prices are very fair (at or below ebay sales value), especially considering it’s a resale shop.

First time visiting. I had a bunch of star wars figures to sell. Gave me a good price. Instead of cash I was able to buy 2 vintage star wars figures for my collection. The owner was very friendly and knowledgeable. I will definitely be coming back. I highly recommend Lost Trove Collectibles to everyone.

I've been going to this place virtually every weekend since John has opened. Every time we go it's an amazing time. I've both sold and bought a lot of stuff from him and whether I'm selling or buying I've gotten a good deal! 10/10 would recommend selling or buying!