Hidden Gem Sports Collectibles in Hackettstown, NJ

Hidden Gem is a great local card store. Lou Jr. and Lou Sr. are very patient and knowledgeable. My boys and I were new to the PSA grading submissions and they walked us through the process. To date, we've had 4 cards submitted to PSA for grading by Hidden Gem and all 4 have come back with a PSA 10 grading!

Happened to be visiting a friend in town and while waiting for him to get ready stumbled upon this "hidden gem" of a card collectable shop. Went in to kill some time and got to talking with the team there.

This place is the real deal and is appropriately named. It's very difficult to find sports card stores like this with personable staff that aren't socially awkward and hostile to customers. Lots of boxes to sift through with chairs so you can take your time.

Support local business!! Great father and son shop. Always a great experience and friendly services. Very knowledgeable with attention to detail and communication when sending cards for grading. A++++++