Home › Ohio › East Liverpool › Critical Games and Hobbies
Critical Games and Hobbies in East Liverpool, OH
Critical Games and Hobbies sells trading cards at 16761 St Clair Ave, East Liverpool, OH. It has a 4.7-star rating from 109 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon and Flesh and Blood.
Games carried
-
Magic: The Gathering
More Magic shops →“I started going there when my brother brought me down because we both played a lot of magic the gathering.” (Google review)
Mentioned 8 times in reviews
-
Pokémon
More Pokémon shops →“Dug through their Pokemon singles box for like an hour while chatting with Donnie and his family.” (Google review)
Mentioned 5 times in reviews
-
Flesh and Blood
More Flesh and Blood shops →“They have a great selection of Pokémon Cards, Magic the Gathering and Flesh and Blood cards.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
Sell your cards here?
“I recently sold my collection of MTG (Magic the Gathering) card to Don.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now and whether they pay cash or store credit.
What collectors say
-
Tournaments & events
“I have been going to FNM here for a couple months now.” (Google review)
Mentioned 4 times in reviews
-
Big singles selection
“Small selection of sealed product for TCGs however, singles I can't rate due to mostly being focused on online sales.” (Google review)
Mentioned 3 times in reviews
-
Play space
“Game play space in the back, mostly casual formats.” (Google review)
Mentioned once in reviews
-
Sealed product
“I just wish the store had more sealed product available but I guess when your community love you and your prices are fair, product will fly off the shelves quickly.” (Google review)
Mentioned 2 times in reviews
From Google reviews
Awesome experience there! The owners were extremely friendly!! Chatted up some old school mtg and grabbed some cards. The best part?? Extremely honest.....had a card worth more than what I wanted and they both told me this. I was still willing to make the deal because it’s a storefront, they pay rent.
Critical Games and Hobbies is the areas BEST game store. With a great selection of board games and Table Top Miniature Games, War Gaming, and of course RPG games; this place can’t be beat! They have a great selection of Pokémon Cards, Magic the Gathering and Flesh and Blood cards.
Honest, fair, reasonable, and genuinely nice. If you are looking at downsizing your collection or just outright sell. I highly recommend Don and Critical games and hobbies to be the only place you go. His customer service is beyond reproach and you can see his genuine love for table top gaming.
I stopped in here to see if there was a list of how to collect pokemon cards. The owner gave me a run down now only on how collections work, but all the information I needed to know about starting a new collection. He was extremely helpful, super nice, and even the other customers are nice and helpful.
Where to find Critical Games and Hobbies
More card shops nearby
Steel City Hobbies
4.8★
Card shops in nearby cities
- Beaver Falls, PA3 card shops
- Monaca, PA1 card shop
- Weirton, WV2 card shops
- Wintersville1 card shop
- Ellwood City, PA1 card shop
- Sewickley, PA1 card shop
- Follansbee, WV1 card shop
- Salem1 card shop