Home › New York › East Islip › Bleacher Creature Collectibles

Bleacher Creature Collectibles in East Islip, NY

5 ★★★★★ 5 Google reviews

New shop Sports cards

Bleacher Creature Collectibles sells trading cards at 7 Maynard Ln, East Islip, NY. It has a 5-star rating from 5 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries sports cards.

Games carried

Each game is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • “If you're looking for a trustworthy and knowledgeable sports card shop, this is definitely a place I would recommend.” (Google review)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

What the shop's website lists

  • Box breaks

    Per the shop's website

From Google reviews

I've done a lot of business with this shop over time and I can honestly say the experience has always been great. The owner is extremely knowledgeable about the hobby and always takes the time to answer questions and help out when needed. Helped me with my first Aaron Judge Baseball Auto.

★★★★★ Vic, Mar 2026

It was a pleasure working with Sal at Bleacher Creatures Collectibles. Extremely knowledgeable about the product and made the process extremely easy. I’ve done multiple deals with him and will continue doing deals with him. Highly recommend doing business with Sal!!

★★★★★ Nicholas, Mar 2026

Amazing to interact with! Easy to work with, even better deals, Very knowledgeable about the Sports Card business! Would 100% recommend and vouch to anyone! Shop here!

★★★★★ Angel, Apr 2026

Sal is a nice guy and easy to deal with. He’s got a good variety and is priced fair. I highly recommend shopping with him.

★★★★★ Alfonso, Apr 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 5 on Google →

Where to find Bleacher Creature Collectibles

More card shops nearby

64 E Main St, East Islip, NY

4.3Rating
24Reviews
—Games

1.3 miles away

TCG DEPOT

4.9★

10 E Main St, East Islip, NY

Buys collections PokémonMagic: The GatheringLorcana
4.9Rating
72Reviews
3Games

1.4 miles away

2650 Sunrise Hwy, East Islip, NY

4.4Rating
69Reviews
—Games

2.3 miles away

87B Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY

Pokémon
4.9Rating
169Reviews
1Games

2.5 miles away

77A Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY

PokémonMagic: The Gathering
4.6Rating
176Reviews
2Games

2.5 miles away

941 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY

Sports cardsPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!
4.6Rating
19Reviews
3Games

2.8 miles away

All card shops in East Islip, NY →

Card shops in nearby cities

All card shops in New York →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.