Home › New Jersey › Fair Lawn › America's Pastime
America's Pastime in Fair Lawn, NJ
America's Pastime sells trading cards at 25-05A Broadway, Fair Lawn, NJ. It has a 4.1-star rating from 91 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it carries sports cards and Pokémon.
Games carried
-
Sports cards
More sports card shops →“Shop has the right atmosphere for a neighborhood baseball card shop: cramped with cards, not overly fancy, and the stock is out for review so you know quickly what's available.” (Google review)
Mentioned 7 times in reviews · Listed on the shop's website
-
Pokémon
More Pokémon shops →“Went in for some Pokémon cards for my nephew, great selection and service, would go back.” (Google review)
Mentioned 2 times in reviews
From Google reviews
Rich is an awesome guy. Whatever cards you need he'll go out of his way to make sure you get it. I've been looking for a complete 93' SP for a long time and he found it within a day. And if you're running low on funds you can make a layaway account with him. Just great service. Now I finally have my Jeter rookie card.
I enjoyed going to this shop. A good selection of cards, both vintage and new, and nice sports memorabilia available. Owner is pleasant and the cards are right out for inspection with prices clearly marked for review. The owner is willing to deal appropriately.
I stopped in to America;s pastime and was taken back by the quality and amount of vintage cards in this store. They are one of the few stores that carries all sports. The owner was very friendly and knowledgable. I ended up buying a Sandy Koufax card as well as several football cards. The price was very fair.
Went into America’s Pastime today and met Rich - what a nice guy. I’m very happy with my purchase and very lucky to have found a new sports memorabilia store to go to where the atmosphere is inviting and am offered a wide variety to shop from.
Where to find America's Pastime
More card shops nearby
Kid Motors Pokemon
3.9★
KMTV Trading Cards
3.7★
Big Pack Hobby Shop
4.5★
Card shops in nearby cities
- Rochelle Park1 card shop
- Paramus3 card shops
- Saddle Brook2 card shops
- Hawthorne1 card shop
- Hackensack1 card shop
- North Haledon2 card shops
- Midland Park2 card shops
- Hasbrouck Heights1 card shop