Home › Best card shops › Wisconsin
Best card shops in Wisconsin
How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 183 of the 217 card shops we list in Wisconsin qualify; these are the top 10.
-
#1 BMW Sportscards
5★★★★★ 2,766 reviews
Sports cardsPokémon“This has been, by far, the best customer experience of my life. Brian goes well above and beyond to satisfy the needs of his customers. I truly can’t recommend this place, or him in general, enough. I…”
-
#2 Noble Knight Games
4.7★★★★★ 1,582 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!“I have been buying from them online for years. I finally had a chance to visit and was not disappointed. Nay. I was thrilled, almost overwhelmed. The staff is friendly, helpful, and engaging. The stor…”
-
#3 PayMore - Buy, Sell & Trade Electronics
4.8★★★★★ 794 reviews
Pokémon“Jeremy was super attentive to my needs, and thoroughly went through my items that I was selling to make sure I got every dollar I deserved. He was friendly, upbeat, had great conversation as well as k…”
-
#4 Chimera Hobby Shop Inc
4.6★★★★★ 745 reviews
Magic: The GatheringPokémonOne Piece“Friendly staff, I've been going here with my friends for awhile, comic book variety is amazing. The stock they carry on Warhammer is a bit lacking, mostly with 40k. You got your space marines in good…”
-
#5 I'm Board! Games & Family Fun - Middleton
4.8★★★★★ 687 reviews
PokémonMagic: The Gathering“Looks like a cool place! The prices on games are a good price (from the ones I compared). They have a large new section and in the back right there are consignment games being sold. I love these secti…”
-
#6 Adventure Games and Hobby
4.8★★★★★ 596 reviews
PokémonMagic: The Gathering“I found the store via TikTok, which the creator is very interactive on her lives and answers tons of questions about the store and things found within the store. The location is downtown where plenty…”
-
#7 River City Hobbies
4.6★★★★★ 589 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringLorcana“Very friendly staff, had quite a few things in there I didn't know they stocked! Will be back for a few Frisbee disc's!”
-
#8 Kryptonite Kollectibles
4.6★★★★★ 533 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne PieceSports cards“I’m new to the Pokémon tcg thing so when I first discovered this shop I was honestly quite surprised. I visit more than I should and probably spend more than I should but the staff have always been ki…”
-
#9 Board Game Barrister
4.6★★★★★ 509 reviews
Magic: The GatheringPokémon“We really enjoyed our time at the game store. They have open gaming on Thursday nights. Pretty awesome. Hundreds of games to play. And refreshments for sale. On most nights you can rent a table for a…”
-
#10 Kowabunga Comics
4.8★★★★★ 479 reviews
PokémonMagic: The Gathering“James has created an awesome comic books, action figures and gaming oasis for adults & young adults alike ... James' incredible passion for the industry and breadth of knowledge makes for some really…”
