Home › Best card shops › Vermont
Best card shops in Vermont
How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 17 of the 19 card shops we list in Vermont qualify; these are the top 10.
-
#1 Underground Closet
5★★★★★ 290 reviews
Pokémon“I went to this place when it was on Main Street and certainly did not have enough space, but you have to start somewhere. I bought three pairs from them before everything hit the fan. Photo included.…”
-
#2 Vermont Gaming Academy
4.6★★★★★ 279 reviews
Yu-Gi-Oh!PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece“Great place to go for classic games! Also a great selection of board games, cards, gaming consoles and peripheals and all sorts of stuff! They gurantee their items work abd all the prices are very fai…”
-
#3 Quarterstaff Games
4.7★★★★★ 269 reviews
Magic: The GatheringPokémonLorcana“They were extremely kind and generous with us. The proprietors really appreciate and celebrate the joy of gaming and building. A true delight (they enjoyed seeing the children playing with the toys)”
-
#4 Black Knight: Anime, Games, & More!
4.9★★★★★ 112 reviews
One Piece“This place really is a diamond in the rough. Every time I come here, there's always something new to see and it's easy to spend far more time in the store than originally planned. Prices are reasonabl…”
-
#5 Main Street Sports Cards
4.6★★★★★ 117 reviews
Sports cards“Great place, Great owner, great prices. This is by far the best card shop around. The owner always has stuff put aside for me and always gives me a great deal. I just moved to NY and now I live 1.5hrs…”
-
#6 Tinker & Smithy Game Store
4.8★★★★★ 105 reviews
Magic: The GatheringPokémon“I love going to the game store due to the wide selection of games. An extra bonus is that the store owner is super chill.”
-
#7 Wonder Cards & Comics
3.7★★★★☆ 112 reviews
Magic: The GatheringPokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-Oh!“What a great shop. I have been driving by this little gem for years and after getting back into the card collecting hobby I finally made it a priority to stop in.”
-
#8 Guardian Cards and Comics
4.8★★★★★ 85 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne PieceStar Wars: Unlimited“We've been shopping with this place well before they had this shop. The original owner we have been shopping with since he was running his business out of his home and on the road at comic conventions…”
-
#9 Green Mountain Sports Cards & Gaming
4.3★★★★☆ 83 reviews
Buys collections PokémonSports cardsMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!“Woody and Chris are great. They have a fantastic inventory and their prices are extremely fair. My son and I drove a long way to see them and we couldn't be happier. Looking forward to visiting them a…”
-
#10 Jim's Sports
4.3★★★★☆ 78 reviews
PokémonSports cardsMagic: The Gathering“Always good business when I shop at Jim’s Sports. They’ve always taken care of me and I strongly recommend. Just bought a 2026 Topps Chrome Black from the shop and pulled an Ohtani /50! Thank you fell…”
