Home › Best card shops › Pennsylvania

Best card shops in Pennsylvania

How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 300 of the 349 card shops we list in Pennsylvania qualify; these are the top 10.

  1. #1 Steel City Collectibles Retail Store

    4.9★★★★★ 3,867 reviews

    White Oak, PA · 1931 Lincoln Way
    Score 18,948 (4.9 × 3,867)

    Sports cards

    “Was in Pittsburgh to catch the Reds game last week, stopped in to see the store. I travel all over the country visiting local shops as much as I can. I was immediately impressed with how much inventor…” From a 5★ Google review

  2. #2 Just Press Play Mega Store

    4.7★★★★★ 1,156 reviews

    Lancaster, PA · 2007 Lincoln Hwy E
    Score 5,433 (4.7 × 1,156)

    PokémonOne Piece

    “What a gem. We always drive by this place and never went in. We decied to go on this time. From the outside it looks small. But when you step in its a heaven. So many options available for video game.…” From a 5★ Google review

  3. #3 Brave New Worlds

    4.7★★★★★ 704 reviews

    Willow Grove, PA · 433 W Moreland Rd
    Score 3,309 (4.7 × 704)

    PokémonMagic: The Gathering

    “I was looking everywhere for Gundam model kits and they didn’t have any but when I went to this store and saw the Gundams I was extremely happy and had a hard time choosing the gundams cause they all…” From a 5★ Google review

  4. #4 New Dimension Comics - Waterfront

    4.6★★★★★ 646 reviews

    Homestead, PA · 630 E Waterfront Dr
    Score 2,972 (4.6 × 646)

    PokémonMagic: The Gathering

    “The ultimate N.E.R.D store!! (Never.Ending.Radical.Dude) I personally am not into comic books but once I found that they carry comic books based on some of my favorite cartoons I was intrigued. They h…” From a 5★ Google review

  5. #5 Adventurer's Guild Games and Hobbies

    4.8★★★★★ 589 reviews

    Mechanicsburg, PA · 1010 Wesley Dr Ste 111
    Score 2,827 (4.8 × 589)

    Magic: The GatheringPokémonLorcana

    “The new place is huge! My brother and I stopped in for the first time and their MTG prices are very reasonable. There’s lot of space for playing and a lot of cool stuff. Would recommend checking this…” From a 5★ Google review

  6. #6 The Games Keep, LLC

    4.9★★★★★ 570 reviews

    West Chester, PA · 561 E Gay St
    Score 2,793 (4.9 × 570)

    Magic: The Gathering

    “Wow! This place has every great game one could hope to find. They even have hard to find items. The games are organized by categories and themes. The shop owner is friendly, VERY knowledgeable, and ca…” From a 5★ Google review

  7. #7 Brave New Worlds

    4.7★★★★★ 576 reviews

    Philadelphia, PA · 55 N 2nd St
    Score 2,707 (4.7 × 576)

    Pokémon

    “Best comic store in Philly! They have something for everyone manga, indies, collectables, artwork, Gundam kits, you name it. The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. Always a joyful experience w…” From a 5★ Google review

  8. #8 Just Press Play

    4.5★★★★★ 562 reviews

    Lancaster, PA · 110 S Centerville Rd
    Score 2,529 (4.5 × 562)

    PokémonOne Piece

    “Great selection as expected and I was able to find what I was looking for. The only reason I am not giving a 5 star is due to how unfriendly the clerk was when I checked out he was not interested in t…” From a 4★ Google review

  9. #9 Cartridges Galore Video Games- Altoona PA

    4.5★★★★★ 543 reviews

    Altoona, PA · 1811 Valley View Blvd
    Score 2,444 (4.5 × 543)

    Pokémon

    “They have fair prices for new and used games as well as good prices to buy games. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They talk games and likes and give advice on purchases if asked.” From a 5★ Google review

  10. #10 Comic Store West

    4.5★★★★★ 531 reviews

    York, PA · 2111 Industrial Hwy
    Score 2,390 (4.5 × 531)

    PokémonMagic: The Gathering

    “The store has just about everything. They have lots of comic books, but their game selection is extensive. The store even has games that one can not find anywhere else. The store also has a very large…” From a 5★ Google review

Games and the "Buys collections" badge appear only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them. Ratings and review counts come from Google and change over time.

All card shops in Pennsylvania