Home › Best card shops › Indiana

Best card shops in Indiana

How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 190 of the 225 card shops we list in Indiana qualify; these are the top 10.

  1. #1 Mega Replay Fort Wayne

    4.3★★★★☆ 2,161 reviews

    Fort Wayne, IN · 5511 Coldwater Rd
    Score 9,292 (4.3 × 2,161)

    Buys collections PokémonYu-Gi-Oh!

    “Good place to buy video games and DVDS! Super cheap! I absolutely love the selection and the way the store is layed out. My favorite sale is the buy 3 & get 6 FREE DVD sale! I can get so many DVDS and…” From a 5★ Google review

  2. #2 Mega Replay

    4.3★★★★☆ 1,942 reviews

    Evansville, IN · 683 N Green River Rd
    Score 8,351 (4.3 × 1,942)

    Pokémon

    “Went in to get my Pokémon Emerald’s internal battery replaced, the gentleman who helped me noticed that the only issue was that the person I got it from, personal sale not from this store, didn’t sold…” From a 5★ Google review

  3. #3 The Hobby Den

    5★★★★★ 921 reviews

    Evansville, IN · 5432 E Indiana St
    Score 4,605 (5 × 921)

    Buys collections PokémonSports cards

    “Great card shop! Very nice young fellows working. Highly recommend you visit and give this LCS business. Thanks guys!” From a 5★ Google review

  4. #4 Rivals Gaming Comics Cards and Hobbies

    4.8★★★★★ 858 reviews

    Mishawaka, IN · 102 N Center St
    Score 4,118 (4.8 × 858)

    PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

    “The owner and staff are all incredibly friendly and welcoming! I spent quite a while checking out their huge Pokémon card wall, trying to find new additions for my collection.” From a 5★ Google review

  5. #5 Family Time Games

    4.8★★★★★ 828 reviews

    Indianapolis, IN · 8796 Michigan Rd
    Score 3,974 (4.8 × 828)

    PokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece

    “Came here today to play in the Star Wars Planetary Qualifiers and I am so grateful to have had such amazing hosts. They treated all the players with respect, the owners dressed up in amazing costumes…” From a 5★ Google review

  6. #6 Hollywood Movies and Games LLC

    4.4★★★★☆ 783 reviews

    Clarksville, IN · 709B E Lewis and Clark Pkwy
    Score 3,445 (4.4 × 783)

    LorcanaPokémonMagic: The GatheringOne Piece

    “For nearly a year Hollywood has made a space for new and casual card game players. For example we have had a whole group form here for One Piece and the group has all become close friends.” From a 5★ Google review

  7. #7 Game Preserve

    4.7★★★★★ 709 reviews

    Indianapolis, IN · 1551 E Stop 12 Rd
    Score 3,332 (4.7 × 709)

    Magic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

    “There are a number of board game shops in indy and this is one of the nicer ones. There was a large selection of games from cards to board games. I liked all the dragons they had in the store. It real…” From a 5★ Google review

  8. #8 Summit Comics & Games

    4.5★★★★★ 690 reviews

    Fort Wayne, IN · 4240 W Jefferson Blvd Ste M-8
    Score 3,105 (4.5 × 690)

    Magic: The GatheringPokémon

    “Really neat comic selection. Quite a few nice little figurines, and board games. They're apparently open 7 days a week too” From a 5★ Google review

  9. #9 Empire Comics & Games

    4.7★★★★★ 651 reviews

    New Albany, IN · 1636 Slate Run Rd
    Score 3,060 (4.7 × 651)

    Magic: The GatheringStar Wars: UnlimitedPokémon

    “They had most of what I wanted in terms of comics, cards, and Tabletop material. They have a wide selection of material, and it is a must for anyone looking to get into comics, tabletop RPGs, and Trad…” From a 5★ Google review

  10. #10 The Book Broker

    4.3★★★★☆ 705 reviews

    Evansville, IN · 2717 Covert Ave
    Score 3,032 (4.3 × 705)

    Buys collections Magic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!Sports cardsPokémon

    “Loved all the sexy guys up front! & Service. Store was clean and organized. Pleassd with the book broker:)” From a 5★ Google review

Games and the "Buys collections" badge appear only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them. Ratings and review counts come from Google and change over time.

All card shops in Indiana